Pizza deliveries

Casey's

A 22-seat kitchen run by Eleni & Yassine, serving the dishes their grandmothers argued about on Tuesday nights in Kreuzberg.

303 N Maguire St, Warrensburg, MO 64093, United States $10–20
2.9
89 notes from regulars
01 The story, in three paragraphs

Why everyone keeps coming back.

Located conveniently at 303 N Maguire St in Warrensburg, MO, Casey's is much more than just a gas station — it’s a dynamic convenience hub that perfectly blends a full-service gas station, a well-stocked convenience store, and a delicious pizza delivery spot all under one roof. Whether you’re fueling up your vehicle, grabbing quick essentials, or craving a freshly made pizza, Casey’s delivers an all-in-one experience that keeps locals coming back.

What truly sets Casey’s apart is its diverse and carefully curated product range. The convenience store shelves boast a selection of signature snacks like Casey’s Mini Pretzels bursting with a perfect balance of salty crunch, and the Dill Pickle Seasoned Pretzel Twists that elevate your snacking routine with a savory dill twist. If you're seeking bold flavors, indulge in their BBQ Pork Rinds, coated with smoky seasoning, or challenge your palate with Hot & Spicy Pork Rinds. For those with a sweet tooth, the Bugles Sweet & Salty Caramel snacks offer a delightful play on textures and tastes.

Meanwhile, pizza lovers will find themselves repeatedly drawn to Casey’s flavorful menu. Their classic Cheese Pizza anchors the lineup with a rich, gooey layer of melted cheese atop their signature marinara. For heartier appetites, the Beef Pizza packs savory satisfaction, generously layered with seasoned beef, while the Canadian Bacon Pizza offers a deliciously smoky twist with ample toppings of tender Canadian bacon. Whether craving a quick bite in-store or enjoying delivery at home, each pizza promises a comforting, fulfilling experience that tastes like a slice of local love.

Customer testimonials provide even more insight into the quality and atmosphere at this Casey’s location. Shane, who experienced a brief wait during a busy shift, was impressed by a staff member’s dedication and generosity in building his pizza, exemplifying the team’s commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Resq Raid highlights the seamless efficiency at the register, praising the cashier’s multitasking skills that keep lines moving swiftly. Regular patrons like Buck Mattson appreciate the friendly, attentive service — especially from standout employees like Kimberly, who skillfully handles busy periods with a smile. Nick, the store manager, is lauded for assembling a strong, all-star team that continues to refine operations with genuine care and enthusiasm.

Whether you’re stopping by for gas, in need of a quick snack, or ordering up a freshly made pizza, Casey’s Warrensburg location embodies a spirit of convenience and community. Friendly faces, quality offerings, and speedy service combine to make it not just a stop along your route, but a welcoming destination that caters thoughtfully to your needs. Experience the perfect intersection of practicality and flavor at Casey's — where every visit feels like coming home.

Contact Info:
303 N Maguire St, Warrensburg, MO 64093, United States
Phone: +1 660-717-2465

03 Notes from regulars

89 notes — the real pulse of the room.

2.9
Based on 89 verified notes
5 49
4 20
3 7
2 6
1 41
All Large Selection Online Ordering Staff Attitude Cappuccino Doughnuts Snacks Cleanliness Pumps Night Shift Guy Friendly Staff
Shane.
2 month ago
I ordered a pizza online tonight, waited ten minutes past the curbside time then went in to see the status. A middle aged man said that the female cook just walked out and he was called in to a frantic set of orders and customers. He quickly made my pizza and was very generous with the ingredients, which I really appreciated after waiting bit. I didn't catch his name, but he did a fine job and had a decent attitude for the situation. Kudos sir.
Save Share
Resq Raid.
3 month ago
I really like how the cashier will operate multiple registers at once. It shows they care about get us in and out.
Save Share
Carol Wetzel.
4 month ago
It's a gas station where you can get everything. The people are friendly.
Save Share
kevin Lewis.
4 month ago
Nick the Manager, has an awesome group of associates working for this location. They took the best of two other locations to make an AllStar team, they are still working out a few kinks of a new store and location but for the most part this store ROCKS!
Save Share
Buck Mattson.
4 month ago
I stop in here every morning to pick up cinnamon roll etc.. And though they are sometimes EXTERMELY busy I am in and out pretty quick. The cashiers are great and friendly, Especially Kimberly, She is quite a multi tasker. But all in all they are all GREAT!!
Save Share
M. MAE KLOEPPEL.
4 month ago
This caseys keeps getting this hate but knob nosters is called Decent but DONT GO to the Knob Noster location it's Gas Station Roof is Leaky and it was pretty Rude Never had any of the Pizza
Save Share
Grover Stuart.
4 month ago
I really like Casey's. I stop there whenever I get the chance. This Casey's is larger than most. The bathrooms are great! Also plenty of fuel pumps.
Save Share
Samantha Grimson.
5 month ago
This location is always great. Quick service. Plenty of drinks. And the store looks bright and welcoming. Thank you
Save Share
04 When to visit & how to find us

Hours & the door on Bergmannstraße.

Opening hours
Monday Open 24 hours
Tuesday Open 24 hours
Wednesday Open 24 hours
Thursday Open 24 hours
Friday Open 24 hours
Saturday (today) Open 24 hours
Sunday Open 24 hours
Finding the door

303 N Maguire St, Warrensburg, MO 64093, United States

05 What makes this place friendly

The details you usually have to call and ask.

Service options
  • Curbside pickup
  • No-contact delivery
  • Delivery
  • Onsite services
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • No Wheelchair accessible seating
Amenities
  • Restroom
Payments
  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
Parking
  • Free parking lot
  • Free street parking
Saved this place? Add a note after your visit.

Notes from real diners are how the next person finds this table. 50–80 words is perfect.

Write my note